A minister of the UK government set-up a draft policy on the Internet in the form of a wiki-type system. Is it a surprise that pranksters descended upon the wiki with a sleuth of funny or embarrassing comments depending on whether you are a visitor (but some jokes are maybe too close to the truth) or in the UK government.
It is pretty amusing to see such a mediatised example of how wikis tagged as web 2.0 are good for fun systems but not for anything important. Allowing anyone to add, edit or delete content is just asking for trouble when the document is of any real importance. While Wikipedia was in its infancy period there were fewer users and issues. Once Wikipedia received ample media coverage they closed down most open functions that allow just anyone to edit content.
This is funny when you see that Wikipedia is often used as an example to differentiate so called web 2.0 systems from web 1.0 sites. It just goes to show that there are far fewer differences than web 2.0 advocates would let you believe, when you compare valid and established systems that don't waste endless hours of editors' time.
This is a snapshot of what the 'defaced' page looked like (clicking on the image, gives you a larger view of the lower part) :
UK Government Wiki Disaster new
Open editable wikis just don't work
Author of the article :
John Garner
Hi,
If you would like to post the first comment about this article "UK Government Wiki Disaster", please fill in the form below and we will add your remarks as soon as possible.
If you are a member, don't forget to log-in before posting a comment. If you would like to be notified about following comments that are posted about this article you'll need to create a free account first.
Note : Functions like posting a comment (and editing it), linking to your personal page, voting and adding article to your bookmark list are services that require a Free account. You don't have an account ? Click here to create a free account now. It only takes a minute.
Click here to go back to the normal article view

Post A Comment About This Article